Shopping for a group health plan for the first time can feel like learning a new language mid-sentence, HMO, PPO, EPO, contribution strategy, minimum participation. None of it is actually complicated once it is broken into steps. Here is the process we walk small business owners through, in order, so you end up with a plan that fits your team and your budget instead of the first option a sales rep pushes.
Small group plans are generally available starting around 2 enrolled employees, though exact rules vary by state. Most carriers also require a minimum percentage of your eligible employees to actually enroll, commonly referred to as a participation requirement, so it helps to have a rough sense of who on your team wants coverage before you start shopping.
You do not have to cover 100 percent of the premium. Most small businesses set a contribution strategy, a fixed dollar amount or percentage per employee, and let employees cover the rest through payroll deduction if they choose a higher tier plan or want to add dependents. Deciding this number first, before you look at specific plans, keeps the rest of the process from turning into sticker shock.
Common approach: many small businesses start by contributing a flat amount toward employee-only coverage, then let employees pay the difference for spouse or family tiers. It is a simple structure that keeps costs predictable for the business.
The three plan types you will see most often:
For a deeper breakdown of how these compare on cost and flexibility, see our HMO vs PPO vs EPO guide.
The cheapest plan on paper is not always the best value. Compare network size in the areas your employees actually live, deductible and out-of-pocket maximum structure, and prescription drug coverage. A broker who represents you, not a single carrier, can run a side-by-side comparison across multiple A-rated insurers instead of you calling each one separately.
Once you pick a plan, employees need a defined enrollment window to select coverage tiers and add dependents. A broker typically handles the paperwork and can run a short enrollment meeting so your team understands their options without pulling you away from running the business.
Group plans renew annually, and premiums can shift based on your group's claims history and the broader market. Reviewing your plan every renewal, rather than auto-renewing without a second look, is how you catch better options before you overpay for another year.
Small group plans are typically available starting around 2 enrolled employees, though exact minimums and participation requirements vary by state and carrier. A broker can confirm what applies in your state.
No. Most small businesses contribute a set percentage or fixed dollar amount per employee rather than the full premium. You choose the contribution level that fits your budget, and employees typically cover the remaining cost through payroll deduction.
HMOs generally require a primary care referral and in-network care, PPOs offer broader network flexibility including out-of-network options at a higher cost, and EPOs sit in between, in-network only but usually without referral requirements. The right choice depends on your team's needs and budget.
Most small group plans can be quoted, compared, and ready for enrollment within a few weeks once you provide basic census information about your team, ages, zip codes, and coverage tier preferences.
Tell us your headcount and budget, we will compare real plans for you, for free.
Get a Free Quote